Wendy’s Twisted Frosty Copycat Recipe (2024)

Today I am remaking a beloved Wendy’s item from the early 2000’s – the Twisted Frosty! Who remembers these? They offered them in four different flavors; Oreo, M&M, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, and Coffee Toffee. This was the Wendy’s version of the McFlurry but SO MUCH BETTER! I don’t go to Wendy’s often, but when I do, I rarely ever leave without at least a snack size Frosty. It’s basically a condiment for my fries 🙂

We start by making my copycat version of the Wendy’s Frosty as the base recipe. You can use this recipe as a standalone recipe, or turn it into a Twisted Frosty by using the mix-ins of your choice.

What is a Wendy’s Twisted Frosty

Thick & Creamy – The Wendy’s Frosty has a thick and creamy texture that’s smooth and drinkable but thick enough to be eaten with a spoon or to dunk crispy, salty fries in.

Full of Mix-In’s – Pick your favorite mix-in! Wendy’s offered Oreo, M&M’s, Coffee Toffee (pictured), and Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough.

Subtle Malty Chocolate Flavor – what gives a Wendy’s Frosty their signature taste is the addition of vanilla ice cream, giving it just a slight chocolate flavor, lighter even than milk chocolate. It’s more of a vanilla-chocolate flavor. There is also a small amount of malt added which most people don’t realize.

Looking for copycat Wendy’s French Fries to dip in the Twisted Frosty’s?

HOW TO MAKE A WENDY’S FROSTY AT HOME

There is one popular recipe for a Wendy’s Frosty floating around on the internet that just annoys me! You’re speaking to someone who DESPISES “whipped topping” aka Cool Whip. The trending recipe is Sweetened Condensed Milk and Cool Whip creating a Wendy’s Frosty. Maybe you like this, or maybe it worked well for you, but sorry, that’s just not my style. Although I realize the true Wendy’s version doesn’t have much more quality ingredients than Cool Whip, I believe in making copycat recipes at home to be better than their restaurant counterpart. Better tasting and better quality! Here is my version, still just four simple ingredients:

• Vanilla ice cream
• Nesquick powder
• Malted milk powder
• milk

HELPFUL TIPS TO MAKE THIS WENDY’S TWISTED FROSTY COPYCAT RECIPE

• Take out the ice cream a few minutes before you plan to make this to ensure the ice cream is easy to scoop into the blender.
• You can easy double this recipe if you’re blender is large enough to handle that liquid capacity. I like to make two at a time and freeze one batch while the other is blending.
• You’d be surprised how little Frosty’s you can make from a quart of ice cream. Plan accordingly if you are making these for a large family.
• If you don’t have malted milk powder you can skip that step and it will still taste delicious. It will just be missing that hint of nostalgia 🙂
• You can adjust the thickness by adding less or more milk. I like to start with just a tad under what the recipes calls for and gradually add more. I found that’s much easier than making it too thin at first and having to add more ice cream to thicken, which throws off the ratios of the other ingredients.

Looking for other delish copycat recipes?

The Travis Scott Burger Copycat Recipe

The Best Five Guys Burger Copycat Recipe

Olive Garden Chicken Alfredo Pizza Fritta Copycat Recipe

McDonald’s Chicken McGriddle Copycat Recipe

KFC Chicken Littles Copycat Recipe

Popeye’s Famous Chicken Sandwich Recipe

CPK Cauliflower Buffalo Bites Copycat Recipe

Chick N’ Cone Copycat Recipe

I look forward to your questions and feedback below. Please be sure to tag me @BadBatchBaking using hashtag #badbatchbaking if you made this recipe and I will feature you on my story! Plus, I LOVE to see your baking accomplishments.